top of page
backBestOne.jpg

Vijilent Blog

Some ideas we feel would be selfish to keep to ourselves

Search

The Veteran Juror: How Military Experience Can Shape the Jury Box

Nov 11
4 min read

Veterans Day is a day to recognize and honor the Americans who have served in the United States Armed Forces. Observed every November 11, the holiday traces its origins to the armistice that ended fighting in World War I and was formally renamed Veterans Day in 1954 to honor American veterans of all wars.

But for those of us who conduct jury research, Veterans Day also presents an opportunity to think about something that matters every day in the courtroom: experience shapes perspective. The question for jury research is not whether a veteran will favor one side or the other. It is whether understanding a juror's experiences can provide attorneys with a more complete picture of the person sitting in the jury box.


Military Experience Can Leave a Lasting Impression

Military service is structured differently from most civilian occupations. Military organizations operate within hierarchical systems in which leadership, accountability, rules, discipline, and responsibility are central components of the environment. Research examining the transition from military to civilian life has found that aspects of this structure and military culture can continue to influence veterans after they leave the service. 

Research has also examined the relationship between military experience and attitudes toward authority. One study published in the American Journal of Sociology specifically investigated whether military experience affected attitudes toward authority and found that the relationship was more complicated than simply assuming that military service produces greater authoritarianism.

That finding is important because two different individuals may have served in the military and walked away with completely different experiences, perspectives, and beliefs. That is precisely why simply knowing that someone served is not enough.


Authority, Credibility, and the Courtroom

Consider how often a trial asks jurors to evaluate authority.

A police officer takes the stand.A physician explains a medical decision.A government official describes a policy.An expert witness offers an opinion.A corporate executive explains a decision.

Jurors must decide which witnesses they find credible and how much weight to give their testimony. Military experience may be relevant to understanding how an individual has interacted with authority, leadership, rules, and responsibility. Research has specifically explored how military culture can influence attitudes toward authority and legitimacy, including research finding that military experiences may have lasting effects on attitudes toward authority.

A veteran's military background should not automatically translate into an assumption that the juror trusts police officers, favors government institutions, respects every person in a position of authority, or will be more receptive to a particular side's argument. In fact, research has demonstrated that the relationship between military experience and attitudes toward authority can be complex. Therefore, the objective is not to make assumptions but to uncover context.

Traditional jury questionnaires and voir dire can identify important pieces of a juror's background. Federal Judicial Center resources include examples of juror questionnaires and materials addressing jury selection and voir dire. A questionnaire might reveal that a prospective juror served in the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marine Corps, Coast Guard, or Space Force.

Depending on the case, a prospective juror’s military experience may raise questions worth exploring during voir dire. The goal is not to investigate a veteran simply because they served, but to understand any experiences or perspectives that may be relevant to the issues being tried. 


Looking Beyond the Uniform

Social media and publicly available information can provide additional context about prospective jurors in different ways. The Federal Judicial Center has specifically examined attorneys' use of social media to research potential jurors during voir dire, as well as jurors' use of social media during trials and deliberations. It is important to distinguish that social media can be incomplete, sarcastic, outdated or unrelated to how a person would potentially evaluate evidence in a specific case. However, as mentioned before it can provide context to certain perspectives that relate to that specific case they become a part of as a prospective jury member. 

For jury researchers, the objective is not to reduce a person to their military background. A veteran is not simply a veteran. They are an individual whose military experience is one part of a much larger story. Their publicly available interests, communication style, professional history, community involvement, and other observable characteristics may provide additional context that helps attorneys understand who they are actually dealing with when they enter the courtroom.


Experience Is Not a Verdict

Perhaps the most important takeaway is also the simplest: Military service does not determine how someone will decide a case. A veteran can be skeptical of authority while another may place tremendous trust in it. One may have had a positive military experience versus another may have had a difficult one. One may strongly identify with their military service years later and another may rarely discuss it.

The same is true of every other characteristic attorneys encounter during jury selection. That is why effective jury research requires looking at the whole person, rather than assuming a single characteristic tells the entire story.


This Veterans Day, Look Beyond the Uniform

Veterans Day is an opportunity to recognize the service and sacrifice of America’s veterans. It is also a reminder that people bring a lifetime of experiences into the courtroom. For jury researchers,  the goal is not to draw conclusions from a single characteristic, but to consider relevant information in context. Military service may be one part of a person’s story, alongside professional experiences, personal values, community connections, and countless other influences. 

Every juror has a story. Military service may be an important or pivotal chapter, but it is never the entire book.


 
 
 

1 Comment


mmartin22
6 days ago

Our occupations definitely leave their impressions upon us and our life outlook! I would think that this is definitely the case for those in the military. It is true, though, that assumptions or generalities cannot be made about those who serve as to their ideologies or leanings. It is definitely something to be considered in the process of fair juror selection.

Like

Ready to get a competitive edge?

bottom of page